Understanding the Basics of Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India
Introduction
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) represents a groundbreaking reform in India's indirect tax system, aimed at unifying the nation’s diverse tax structure into a single, streamlined framework. By consolidating multiple Central and State taxes and enabling seamless credit for taxes paid at prior stages, GST eliminates the cascading tax effect, creating a more transparent and efficient tax environment. One of the most profound advantages for consumers has been the reduction in the overall tax burden on goods, previously estimated at 25%-30%, which has enhanced affordability and purchasing power.
For businesses, GST fosters competitiveness by reducing production costs and aligning India with global trade standards. Studies suggest that the introduction of GST has the potential to boost economic growth significantly, driven by a widened tax base, increased trade volumes, and improved compliance. Additionally, its transparent design simplifies administration, making it a game-changer for tax authorities and taxpayers alike. This article explores the fundamental aspects of GST, its objectives, and its transformative impact on India’s economy.
Definition of Goods and Services Tax (GST)?
- The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a type of value-added tax (VAT) imposed on the majority of goods and services consumed domestically. Although consumers bear the cost of GST when purchasing goods or services, the responsibility for remitting the tax to the government lies with the businesses involved in selling those goods or services.
- Despite its efficiency in streamlining taxation, critics argue that GST can disproportionately affect individuals in lower and middle-income brackets, making it a regressive form of taxation. This concern arises from the uniform nature of GST rates, which may place a heavier burden on households with limited income, thereby exacerbating income inequality. To address these challenges, many countries have implemented measures such as reduced GST rates or exemptions on essential items like food and healthcare. Others provide GST credits or rebates to alleviate the financial impact on lower-income households.
Meaning and Scope of GST
- The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a comprehensive, multi-stage tax system levied on goods and services at each stage of value addition, from production to final consumption. It is a destination-based tax, meaning it is charged at the point of consumption, rather than the point of origin. By replacing a plethora of indirect taxes like VAT, excise duty, and service tax, GST has enabled the Indian government to realize its vision of “One Nation, One Tax.”
- GST is levied on goods and services sold within India for domestic consumption. It is calculated based on the final market price, which includes all previous stages of value addition. Customers pay GST as part of the final price when purchasing goods or services, and the seller is responsible for remitting the collected tax to the government. This makes GST an indirect tax, as the burden ultimately falls on consumers but is collected and paid by businesses.
- The tax rate for GST is uniform across India, but different goods and services are placed into categories with varying tax rates. For example, luxury goods fall under higher tax slabs, while essential items are taxed at lower or even zero rates. This classification is aimed at ensuring equitable distribution of wealth, with the goal of supporting lower-income groups by reducing the tax burden on necessities.
Key Features of the Goods and Services Tax (GST)
- Consumption-Based Tax: GST is applicable on the supply of goods or services, replacing the current system that taxes the manufacture and sale of goods or provision of services. It is a destination-based consumption tax, meaning the tax is collected where the goods or services are consumed.
- Dual GST Structure: GST is a dual tax system, where both the Centre and States impose the tax on a common tax base. The tax levied by the Centre on intra-State transactions is called Central GST (CGST), and the tax imposed by the States is called State GST (SGST).
- Exemptions: GST applies to most goods and services, with exceptions. Alcohol for human consumption and five petroleum products—petroleum crude, motor spirit (petrol), high-speed diesel, natural gas, and aviation turbine fuel—are excluded. Tobacco and tobacco products will also be taxed under GST, though additional duties may apply.
- Taxes Replaced by GST: GST subsumes various central and state taxes, including:
1. Central Taxes
a. Central Excise duty
b. Duties of Excise (Medicinal and Toilet Preparations)
c. Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance)
d. Additional Duties of Excise (Textiles and Textile Products)
e. Additional Duties of Customs (commonly known as CVD)
f. Special Additional Duty of Customs (SAD)
g. Service Tax
2. State Taxes:
a. State VAT
b. Central Sales Tax
c. Luxury Tax
d. Entry Tax in lieu of octroi
e. Entertainment Tax (not levied by the local bodies)
f. Taxes on advertisements
g. Purchase Tax
h. Taxes on lotteries, betting and gambling
i. State cesses and surcharges insofar as they relate to supply of goods and services
- Integrated GST (IGST): IGST will be levied on inter-State supply of goods and services, collected by the Centre. The tax is later transferred to the destination State based on consumption, ensuring equitable distribution.
- Input Tax Credit: Taxpayers can claim input tax credit on taxes paid for inputs and use it to offset output tax. However, credits for CGST cannot be used for SGST and vice versa. IGST credits can be used across CGST, SGST, and IGST.
- HSN Code Classification: Goods under GST will be classified using the Harmonised System of Nomenclature (HSN). Businesses with turnover between Rs. 1.5 crore and Rs. 5 crore will use a 2-digit code, while those with turnover above Rs. 5 crore will use a 4-digit code.
- Exports as Zero-Rated Supply: Exports are considered zero-rated under GST, meaning no tax is payable on export goods. However, exporters can claim input tax credit for the goods exported.
- Imports: Imports of goods and services will be treated as inter-State supplies, attracting IGST along with applicable customs duties.
- Harmonization of Laws: The CGST and SGST regulations will be harmonized to simplify the tax structure across both the Centre and States.
Evolution and Implementation of Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India
The journey of Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India has been long and complex, spanning over 17 years from its initial introduction to its eventual implementation in 2017. Below are the key milestones in the history of GST and the important developments leading to its establishment:
1. Initial Concept and Formation of Committee
- In 2000, the then Prime Minister of India proposed the concept of Goods and Services Tax (GST).
- A committee was set up to draft a new law for indirect taxation in India, marking the first step towards GST implementation.
2. Task Force and Need for Reform
- A task force recommended the implementation of GST to address issues within the existing indirect tax system.
- The objective was to streamline the tax structure, eliminate tax cascading, and improve tax compliance.
3. GST Scheduled for 1st April 2010
- The Finance Minister of India announced that GST would be introduced on 1st April 2010.
- The decision was made to phase out the Central Sales Tax (CST), with its rates reduced from 4% to 3%.
4. Dual GST Structure Finalized
- The GST structure was finalized, focusing on a dual tax system, which involved separate laws and levies for the Centre and States.
- The Empowered Committee (EC) of State Finance Ministers finalized the dual structure.
5. Delay in Introduction and Structural Hurdles
- The introduction of GST was delayed due to structural and implementation challenges.
- A project was launched for the computerisation of commercial taxes to help with the transition.
6. Constitution Amendment Bill and Parliamentary Discussion
- A Constitution Amendment Bill was introduced to enable the passage of the GST law.
- Discussions on GST were initiated by the Standing Committee, but the process was stalled due to lack of clarity on Clause 279B of the Bill.
7. Reintroduction of GST Bill
- After various amendments, the Finance Minister reintroduced the Goods and Services Tax Bill to Parliament.
- The Lok Sabha cleared the bill, but it faced delays in the Rajya Sabha due to political and procedural issues.
9. Approval and Passage in Parliament
- The Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN) was launched, and the law's amended model was passed by both Houses of Parliament.
- The Bill received presidential assent, signaling a significant step forward.
10. Final Approval and Implementation
- In May 2017, the Cabinet approved four supplementary bills related to GST, which were cleared by both the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha.
- GST was officially implemented on 1st July 2017, marking a landmark moment in India's taxation system.
Example of India's GST Implementation
- India's adoption of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in 2017 marked a significant shift in the country's tax framework, simplifying the indirect tax structure that had been in place for decades. The dual GST structure, which includes both Central and State components, aims to eliminate the cascading effect of taxes and bring about a unified tax system.
- Before GST, taxes were levied at multiple stages of the production and distribution chain. For instance, a manufacturer of notebooks would pay tax on raw materials, and when the product reached the retailer, it would incur tax again. This "tax on tax" system led to a higher tax burden for consumers. The GST system eliminates this issue by allowing businesses to claim credits for taxes paid at previous stages, thereby reducing the overall tax burden.
- For example, when a manufacturer buys raw materials worth Rs. 10 with a 10% tax, the tax paid is Rs. 1. When the manufacturer adds value to the goods, the total value becomes Rs. 15, and the new tax due is Rs. 1.50. The tax already paid (Rs. 1) is deducted, resulting in a final tax of Rs. 0.50. This process is applied at each stage, ensuring a seamless tax flow through the supply chain.
GST Tax Slabs in India
India implemented several GST tax rates to classify goods and services based on their nature. These include:
a. 0%: For essential items like food, books, and healthcare.
b. 5%: On common household goods like tea, sugar, and coffee.
c. 12%: For products like computers and processed food.
d. 18%: On items like soap, toothpaste, and industrial goods.
e. 28%: For luxury items such as cars, cigarettes, and high-end electronics.
These rates aim to ensure that necessary items are kept affordable while higher taxes are applied to luxury goods, contributing to wealth distribution.
Objectives of GST
1. Achieving the Ideology of ‘One Nation, One Tax’
- Explanation: GST replaces multiple indirect taxes across India with a uniform tax system. This ensures a standard rate for goods and services across states, making tax administration more centralized and streamlined.
- Benefits: Unified tax rates simplify compliance, reduce inter-state trade barriers, and promote consistency in tax administration.
2. Subsuming Multiple Indirect Taxes
- Explanation: Earlier, taxes like Service Tax, VAT, Central Excise, and Entry Tax were levied at different points in the supply chain. GST subsumes most of these into one, creating a central and uniform tax system.
- Benefits: Reduces the compliance burden for businesses, making it easier for taxpayers and tax authorities to manage.
3. Eliminating the Cascading Effect of Taxes
- Explanation: GST enables input tax credit (ITC) for the taxes paid at each stage of the supply chain, ensuring the tax is only levied on the value addition.
- Benefits: Reduces the overall tax burden, lowers prices, and ensures efficient tax management.
Reference: Reports by the CBIC state that GST effectively tackles "tax on tax," a major issue in the pre-GST era.
4. Curbing Tax Evasion
- Explanation: GST’s stringent mechanisms, such as e-invoicing, invoice matching, and centralized monitoring, minimize the scope of tax evasion.
- Benefits: Reduces fraudulent claims, ensures higher revenue collection, and improves accountability.
5. Increasing the Taxpayer Base
- Explanation: GST brought businesses into the tax net with standardized registration thresholds and by targeting informal sectors like construction.
- Benefits: Enhances tax revenue collection and brings transparency to unorganized sectors.
6. Facilitating Online Procedures for Ease of Doing Business
- Explanation: GST enables online processes for registration, return filing, refunds, and e-way bill generation, eliminating the need for manual interventions.
- Benefits: Simplifies compliance, reduces errors, and saves time and resources for businesses.
7. Improving Logistics and Distribution Systems
- Explanation: GST removes the need for multiple check posts and tax documentation for inter-state goods movement.
- Benefits: Reduces transportation time, improves supply chain efficiency, and lowers warehousing costs.
8. Promoting Competitive Pricing
- Explanation: GST eliminates the cascading effect and standardizes tax rates, resulting in lower product prices.
- Benefits: Enhances consumer affordability and boosts demand, leading to higher consumption and revenue.
Reference: Economic surveys indicate a reduction in tax-induced price disparities among states.
9. Encouraging Consumption and Revenue Growth
- Explanation: Lower taxes and improved affordability under GST encourage consumer spending.
- Benefits: Boosts indirect tax revenue and contributes to overall economic growth.
10. Enhancing Transparency and Accountability
- Explanation: Centralized monitoring and digital tools under GST improve visibility in tax collection.
- Benefits: Builds trust among stakeholders and strengthens the financial system.
11. Simplifying Interstate Trade
- Explanation: By removing entry barriers and reducing state-specific taxes, GST facilitates smoother trade across states.
- Benefits: Encourages businesses to operate on a national scale without tax-induced restrictions.
12. Supporting Economic Growth
- Explanation: The unified tax system under GST reduces compliance costs, lowers tax rates, and promotes a business-friendly environment.
- Benefits: Attracts foreign investment, boosts local industries, and drives GDP growth.
Proposed Benefits of GST
1. Dynamic Common Market
- GST creates a unified market across India, eliminating tax rate disparities among states.
- Improves the ease of doing business by ensuring uniformity in indirect tax rates.
2. Elimination of Cascading Effect
- Seamless input tax credit across transactions prevents double taxation.
- Enhances resource allocation efficiency and avoids tax on tax.
3. Increased Efficiency
- Subsuming multiple indirect taxes removes inefficiencies.
- Single tax system makes manufacturers more competitive, boosting exports.
4. Reduced Compliance Costs
- Harmonized tax rates and seamless IT-enabled systems lower compliance expenses.
- Online services like registration, payments, and returns simplify the compliance process.
5. Reduction in Tax Evasion
- Uniform tax rates reduce the incentive for evasion by eliminating rate arbitrage between states.
6. Improved Collection Efficiency
- Lower tax evasion enhances revenue buoyancy for both Union and State governments.
- Simplified classification and assessment procedures improve transparency and reduce disputes.
7. Increased Revenue Generation
- GST’s wide tax base and controlled tax leakage boost revenue for Central and State governments.
8. Encourages Savings and Investment
- As a tax on consumption rather than income, GST promotes savings and investments.
- Lower cost of capital goods through input tax credits encourages investment.
9. Improved Logistics Efficiency
- Eases inter-state goods movement, encouraging consolidation of warehouses.
- Decisions on logistics are now based on operational efficiency rather than tax considerations.
10. Regulation of the Unorganized Sector
- Online compliance and input credit provisions bring accountability to unorganized businesses.
- Promotes formalization of the economy.
11. Export Competitiveness
- Zero-rated exports and streamlined input tax credit make Indian goods internationally competitive.
- Supports initiatives like 'Make in India' by boosting the export sector.
12. Higher Threshold for Registration
- Threshold limit increased to ₹20 lakhs from ₹5 lakhs (for VAT) and ₹10 lakhs (for service tax).
- Exempts many small traders and service providers from GST registration.
13. Composition Scheme for Small Businesses
- Offers simplified compliance for businesses with turnover up to ₹1 crore (₹75 lakhs for special category states).
- Low GST rates for small taxpayers: 0.5% for traders, 1% for manufacturers, and 2.5% for restaurants.
14. Consumer Benefits
- Seamless flow of input tax credits reduces the final price of goods and services.
- Lower average tax burden on businesses leads to reduced consumer prices.
These benefits highlight how GST fosters economic efficiency, promotes compliance, and supports growth across sectors.
Challenges in Implementing GST
1. Lack of Preparedness
- Many businesses are still in the early stages of understanding GST provisions.
- Functional departments, such as IT and legal, struggle to align with compliance mandates.
2. Complex Compliance Requirements
- Businesses must file multiple returns based on their operations, increasing administrative workload.
- Ensuring timely compliance by suppliers is crucial to avoid loss of input tax credit.
3. Higher Costs for Technology Adoption
- Businesses need to invest in GST-compliant software or upgrade existing systems.
- Training employees to use these systems increases operational expenses.
4. Challenges for Small Businesses
- SMEs must adapt quickly to the GST framework, including issuing GST-compliant invoices.
- Compliance involves understanding technicalities like GSTIN, HSN codes, and place of supply.
5. Shortage of Skilled Workforce
- Skilled professionals with in-depth knowledge of GST are limited, creating implementation delays.
- Companies need to re-train existing staff, adding to operational costs.
6. Complex Tax Rate Structure
- The four-tier tax system (5%, 12%, 18%, 28%) complicates tax administration.
- Classifying goods and services into these categories can lead to disputes and inefficiencies.
These challenges emphasize the need for better education, streamlined processes, and skilled personnel to ensure the effective implementation of GST.
Classifications of GST
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) system in India is divided into four classifications based on the type and location of the transaction. These classifications ensure smooth taxation across the nation, considering the federal structure of the country.
1. Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST)
- An indirect tax collected by the Central Government on intra-state (within the same state) transactions of goods and services.
- Compensates the Central Government for indirect taxes that were replaced under GST, such as Central Excise Duty, Service Tax, Customs Duty, and various surcharges and cesses.
- Charged alongside SGST/UTGST, following the Dual GST model.
Example: A retailer in Maharashtra sells goods worth ₹1,00,000 to a consumer in Maharashtra. If GST is 18%, CGST will be 9% of the taxable value.
2. State Goods and Services Tax (SGST)
- Tax levied by the State Government on intra-state transactions.
- Ensures states receive revenue from the consumption of goods and services within their jurisdiction.
- Applicable in all states.
- Also applies to union territories with legislative assemblies, such as Delhi and Puducherry, which have adopted SGST due to their state-like governance structures.
Example: Continuing the above example, the SGST will also be 9%, making the total GST 18%.
3. Union Territory Goods and Services Tax (UTGST)
- Similar to SGST but applicable in Union Territories without legislative assemblies.
- Revenue collected goes to the treasury of the respective union territory, which is directly governed by the Central Government.
- Levied in union territories like Andaman & Nicobar Islands, Lakshadweep, Chandigarh, Dadra & Nagar Haveli and Daman & Diu, Ladakh, and Jammu & Kashmir.
- Excludes Delhi and Puducherry, which levy SGST due to their legislative structures.
Example: If goods worth ₹1,00,000 are sold within Chandigarh, UTGST will be 9%, paired with 9% CGST.
4. Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST)
- Tax levied by the Central Government on inter-state (between different states) and international transactions of goods and services.
- Provides uniform taxation for inter-state supplies and exports, streamlining tax administration and preventing disputes.
- IGST is approximately equal to the sum of CGST and SGST.
- Revenue Distribution:Collected by the Central Government.
- Later apportioned between the Central and State Governments based on consumption.
Example: A supplier in Maharashtra sells goods worth ₹1,00,000 to a buyer in Gujarat. IGST will be charged at 18% (entire amount goes to the Centre initially, then shared).
Example to Illustrate GST Classifications
Tax Laws Before GST
- Under the earlier indirect tax system in India, multiple taxes were levied by both the state and central governments. States primarily imposed Value Added Tax (VAT), with each state having its own rules and rates. For inter-state transactions, the central government levied Central Sales Tax (CST). Additional indirect taxes such as entertainment tax, octroi, and local taxes were collected by both state and central authorities, resulting in overlapping and inefficient taxation.
- For instance, when goods were manufactured, the central government levied excise duty. Subsequently, when the same goods were sold, VAT was imposed by the state. This led to a "tax on tax" scenario, commonly referred to as the cascading effect of taxes.
- Below is a comparison of taxes before and after GST:
- Some non-GST goods, such as petroleum products, alcoholic beverages, and certain transactions (e.g., resale or manufacturing), remain outside the GST framework and are taxed separately.
How GST Reduced Prices
Before GST, every buyer in the supply chain, including the final consumer, bore the burden of cascading taxes. GST removed this cascading effect by introducing a mechanism to claim input tax credit, ensuring tax was levied only on value addition.
For example, consider the production and sale of biscuits:
Pre-GST Tax Calculation:
- Manufacturer sells at ₹1,000 + 10% tax = ₹1,100.
- Warehouse repacks, adding ₹300 and charging 10% on ₹1,400 = ₹1,540.
- Retailer adds ₹500, with 10% tax on ₹2,040 = ₹2,244.
- The cumulative tax burden results in a final price of ₹2,244.
Post-GST Tax Calculation:
- Manufacturer charges ₹1,000 + 10% GST = ₹1,100.
- Warehouse adds ₹300, paying GST only on value addition (₹300 × 10% = ₹30) = ₹1,430.
- Retailer adds ₹500, paying GST on value addition (₹500 × 10% = ₹50) = ₹1,980.
The final price drops to ₹1,980 due to the ability to claim input tax credit at each stage. This streamlined taxation reduces costs for consumers and enhances efficiency in the economy.
Concepts of GST Levy – Multi-Stage, Destination-Based, and Value-Added
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) system is structured to apply at every stage of production, ensuring that value-added at each point is taxed. Additionally, it operates on a destination-based model, where the tax is levied at the point of consumption, not the point of origin.
Here’s a breakdown of these key concepts:
1. Multi-Stage Levy
- The multi-stage levy refers to the fact that GST is applied at every point in the supply chain, from production to final consumption. Each time the goods move to a new stage—whether it's raw materials being processed, goods being stored, or items being sold—the GST is levied. Ultimately, the tax burden falls on the final consumer, but it is paid at each stage of the transaction.
- The typical stages of production and sale of a good under this system are:
a. Raw Material Purchase: Buying the initial raw materials.
b. Manufacture/Production: Converting raw materials into finished goods.
c. Storage: Storing the finished goods in a warehouse.
d. Sale to Wholesaler: The wholesaler purchases the goods.
e. Sale to Retailer: The retailer buys the goods.
f. Sale to Consumer: The goods are sold to the end user.
g. Each of these stages involves the collection of GST, making it a multi-stage taxation system.
2. Destination-Based Levy
- A destination-based levy means that the tax is applied where the goods or services are consumed rather than where they are produced. This concept ensures that the state or region where the goods are used, rather than where they are manufactured, is the one that collects the tax.
- This principle differentiates between the 'supply' of goods and the 'place of supply'. The classification of whether a transaction is interstate or intrastate depends on the location where the goods are ultimately consumed, not where they originated.
3. Taxation on Value Addition
- GST is applied to the value added at each stage of production or processing. As goods move through various stages—each adding monetary value to the product—GST is levied on the increase in value.
- For instance, let’s consider the production process of Britannia biscuits in Chennai:
Stage 1: The raw ingredients like flour and sugar are processed into dough, baked into biscuits, adding value to the raw materials.
Stage 2: The biscuits are sent to the warehouse for storage and further processing. They are then packed into sets of 10, which increases their value.
Stage 3: The biscuits are labeled with the brand logo, representing another added value.
Stage 4: Finally, the packed biscuits are placed into cartons and relabeled for retail, further enhancing their value.
At each of these stages, GST is applied on the increased value, ensuring the tax is collected based on the value added at every point in the production and distribution process. This approach helps create a seamless and transparent tax system where value-added at each stage is taxed accordingly.
Concept of Input Tax Credit (ITC) under GST in India
- Input Tax Credit (ITC) is a key feature of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) system in India, designed to eliminate the cascading effect of taxes and reduce the overall tax burden on businesses. ITC allows businesses to claim credit for the taxes they pay on inputs (purchases) against the taxes they collect on outputs (sales). This ensures that businesses only pay tax on the value added at each stage of production, rather than on the entire value of the goods or services.
- When a registered business purchases goods or services, it pays GST on those items (known as input tax). Later, when the same business sells goods or services, it collects GST from the customer (known as output tax). The business can then offset the input tax against the output tax liability, thereby reducing the amount of GST to be paid to the government.
- Example:
Suppose a manufacturer sells a product and the output tax is Rs. 450. If this manufacturer paid Rs. 300 as input tax when purchasing raw materials, he can claim the Input Tax Credit of Rs. 300. As a result, the manufacturer only needs to pay the difference of Rs. 150 (i.e., Rs. 450 – Rs. 300) to the government.
Case Laws Related to GST in India
Here are some recent case laws related to Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India that have shaped the interpretation and implementation of the GST law:
1. Union of India v. Bharti Airtel Ltd. (2021)
Issue: Rectification of Form GSTR-3B for the period from July to September 2017
Background: Bharti Airtel Ltd. sought rectification of its GSTR-3B form for the period of July to September 2017 due to errors. The Delhi High Court allowed the rectification, striking down Circular No. 26/26/2017-GST, which restricted the rectification of GST returns only to the period in which the error occurred. The High Court ruled that the Circular was arbitrary.
The Revenue challenged this order, and the matter went to the Supreme Court.
Decision: The Supreme Court upheld the validity of the impugned Circular. The Court observed that the Circular allows rectification of errors in subsequent periods, thus providing taxpayers the chance to correct omissions or incorrect details in the returns filed for later periods when errors are discovered. The Court also emphasized that this does not deny the taxpayer the right to claim Input Tax Credit (ITC). The Court found the Circular was issued under the power of Section 168(1) of the CGST Act, 2017, and was not in conflict with Section 39(9) of the same Act. Therefore, the Court upheld the Circular, and the decision of the Delhi High Court was reversed.
2. Sodexo India Services Pvt. Ltd. vs The Union of India and Ors (2022)
Issue: Whether a pre-deposit for Service Tax/Excise matters can be made through Form GST DRC-03.
Decision: The Bombay HC directed the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) to issue guidelines on the pre-deposit procedure using GST DRC-03 for Service Tax/Excise matters, as there was no clear provision in the law for such a mechanism.
3. State of Karnataka vs M/s Ecom Gill Coffee Trading Pvt. Ltd. (2023)
Issue: The issue was whether mere production of invoices or payments by cheque was enough to claim Input Tax Credit (ITC).
Decision: The Supreme Court upheld the rejection of ITC claims, stating that production of invoices or payments by cheque alone is not enough to discharge the burden of proof required under Section 70 of the KVAT Act. The ITC claim was denied as insufficient evidence was provided.
4. Chief Commissioner of CGST vs M/s Safari Retreats Pvt. Ltd.(2023)
Issue: The issue was the levy of GST on rental/lease payments.
Decision: The Supreme Court granted leave to hear the Special Leave Petition (SLP) challenging the Orissa High Court's judgment, which had ruled that GST should apply on rental income.
5. Kishan Lal Kuriya Mal International vs Union of India (2022)
Issue: Whether refund of IGST can be granted on exported goods after deducting the duty drawback.
Decision: The Delhi HC allowed the refund of IGST on exported goods, even after deducting the duty drawback, ruling in favor of the petitioner.
Conclusion
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) has revolutionized India's indirect tax system by replacing multiple taxes with a unified framework that promotes efficiency, transparency, and economic growth. While its implementation has faced challenges such as compliance complexities and the need for technological adoption, the long-term benefits are evident in the reduced cascading effect of taxes, improved tax compliance, and a more competitive business environment. By fostering a common national market and encouraging the formalization of the economy, GST is poised to stimulate economic growth, enhance revenue generation, and improve ease of doing business. However, continuous efforts in simplifying processes and ensuring that small businesses are equipped to comply will be key to realizing the full potential of this tax reform.
By harmonizing tax collection and enhancing compliance, GST has created a more efficient and predictable tax environment. As a result, it fosters economic growth, enhances competitiveness, and reduces tax evasion, benefiting both businesses and consumers.
References
1. Indirect Taxes: Law and Practice by V.S. Datey
2. GST in India by S.K. Mehta
3. Basics of GST by Nitya Tax Associates
4. Systematic Approach to Income Tax by Dr. Girish Ahuja, Dr. Ravi Gupta
5. Goods & Services Tax Manual by Ravi Pulliani
6. Worldwide VAT, GST and Sales Tax Guide 2022: India, Page:728 by Ernst & Young,
7. The Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
8. https://www.gst.gov.in/
9. https://groww.in/p/tax/types-of-gst
10. https://cleartax.in/s/gst-law-goods-and-services-tax
11. https://vikaspedia.in/social-welfare/financial-inclusion/faqs-on-gst-1/faqs-on-gst
AUTHOR CREDENTIALS
NAME: FARJANA AKTER
COURSE: LL.B
UNIVERSITY: LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY
REGISTRATION NUMBER: 12202691
UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF: DR. SYEDAH FATIMA ZAHARA ZAFRI
Comments
Post a Comment